When I was asked to review a book called 'Why Did Nobody Tell Me?' I said yes, especially as I was told that the book "complimented my blog perfectly".
"Drawn from the message boards of mumsnet, this book shapes that collective wisdom into dozens of dos and don'ts that will lead you through the minefield that is twenty-first-century parenting"
I thought the book would be funny, and something I could definitely empathise with. I've always liked books and blog posts like this by
The Boy and Me. The title of the book made me think it would be like that.
When the book first arrived I quickly scanned random pages and thought it was quite funny, then yesterday on the way to a picnic I had my chance to really start reading it.
Davina McCall is quoted on the back of the book as saying:
"This book is full of non-judgemental golden nuggets to empower us to be better women at the same time as just making you smile...a lot"
I must admit that I found this book the opposite and felt it was extremely judgemental. I got as far as page 7 until I felt the book had completely let me down.
Mummy blogs, parenting blogs, whatever you would like to call them, are part of a fantastic community. Publishing a new blog post doesn't mean we were bored enough to blog, it means we had something we wanted to share with our community, with our friends.
Maybe some mummies do blog because they are bored, but how is that a negative thing? Surely it's positive that they have somewhere to go and something to do when they are bored.
Would it be acceptable for me to say that some mums
must be bored to visit Internet forums, or that some mums must be really
bored to start up Internet forums?
No, it wouldn't be acceptable.
Same way as it being unacceptable to write this in a book published by a well-known Internet forum frequented by mummy bloggers.
Blogging has many benefits. It can be a great therapy and escape for
some, a source of advice and friendship, and also a way to record family
life to look back on in years to come. And maybe even to share with our
children later on.
Fair enough, some mums might not post about bad days. But
some do.
As soon as a post like that is published we open ourselves up further
for criticism or judging from other people, which this very book
'full
of non-judgemental golden nuggets' manages to do just perfectly.
I wonder how many blogs the authors have read. I have a few I
regularly read and all feature, at some point, a bad day they've
experienced.
Mummy Mishaps: Bad Mummy,
Mothers Always Right: Meltdown
OneBlueOnePink: I Found Out That Baking Can Be Stressful
Missy B & Family: Meltdown
Bloggomy: What a Carry On!!
Dummy Mummy: When The Battle Is Lost
Maybe we don't feel the need to post about bad days. If we don't all want to let our readers know the naughty things our children do then that should be accepted, not made to be a negative thing, like we are hiding a dirty secret. By not divulging the bad days it doesn't mean we are saying they never happen. Maybe we are trying to forget them.
Do mummy bloggers think they are experts? Do we assume we are experts and therefore have the right to blog about how what we are doing is perfect?
We don't claim to be perfect at all. We share our experiences, our methods, things that have worked for us and things that haven't, to help others.
But not only that, regular readers of mummy blogs will notice that we ask for advice as much as we talk about life being "perfect".
And, shock horror, we don't all claim to feed our children fresh vegetables served alongside free range meat we bought from the farm shop in the picturesque village we live in.We do serve our children fish fingers and chicken nuggets too.
It's a shame this piece was published in the book, as it had great potential.
Being honest I haven't read all of the book, or even half of it, because I was so offended by the above piece. In fact I am passing it on to someone else because I have no desire to read any more of it.
But, maybe this isn't the best book to send to a
bored mummy blogger to review, when it criticises us from the beginning.
And as for it complimenting my blog...I have to highly disagree with that.
Thanks to
TheBoyandMe for helping me to tone down my rant.
I was sent a copy of this book to
offend me and cure my obvious boredom review.